| RESEARCH
IN THE FIELD OF MIND/BODY MEDICINE
The
scientific aspects of mind/body interventions and their clinical
applications, such as the relaxation response (Herbert Benson) and various
other meditation practices have now been researched for at least 30 years.
Mind/body interactions can be measured scientifically. Through the
investigation of stress, the relaxation response, other mind/body
interactions, and belief systems, research attempts to understand these
linkages at various levels and dimensions of human experience. A wealth of
scientific findings helps us understand in ever more intricate details how
body and mind interact, and how to put our knowledge of this interaction
to beneficial use in everyday living.
It
is now scientific fact beyond a doubt that mind/body interventions such as
psychotherapy and meditation have a profoundly healing effect on human
beings. This results in a whole spectrum of positive effects on health,
such as cures, symptom improvements, slowed down disease progressions,
accelerated healing rates, decreased need for surgical and other invasive
interventions, decreased use of clinical investigations and medication,
decreased rates of disease relapses, greater tolerance for chronic pain
and debilitating conditions, lessened anxiety in the face of impending
mortality and simply a greater sense of ease and well-being.
Mindfulness-based
stress reduction (MBSR), the clinical application of mindfulness
meditation as developed by Jon Kabat-Zinn, has become a respected field of
research within the larger context of mind/body medicine. Since 1993, many
papers have been published on MBSR by the research team of the Stress
Reduction Clinic at the University of Massachusetts and other researchers
at other institutions. Some of these papers are included in a separate
section in the bibliography.
Major Research
Findings in Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction (MBSR) as described on the
website of the Center For Mindfulness in Medicine, Healthcare and Society
– Top
of Page
Over
the past twenty years research in MBSR at the Center For Mindfulness in
Medicine, Healthcare and Society at the University of Massachusetts (CFM)
has shown consistent, reliable, and reproducible demonstrations of major
and clinically relevant reductions in medical and psychological symptoms
across a wide range of medical diagnoses. These include many different
chronic pain conditions [Kabat-Zinn, 1982; Kabat-Zinn, Lipworth and
Burney, 1985; Kabat-Zinn et al, 1986], other medical diagnoses [Kabat-Zinn
and Chapman-Waldrop, 1988]; and medical patients with a secondary
diagnosis of anxiety and/or panic [Kabat-Zinn et al, 1992; Miller et al,
1995]. The research was based on the eight-week MBSR intervention, and
showed maintenance of these changes in some cases for up to four years of
follow-up.
Consistent,
reliable, and reproducible demonstrations of significant and clinically
relevant increases in trait measures which are usually stable in
adulthood, and maintenance of these gains for up to three years of
follow-up, were also shown. This is indicative of enhanced psychological
hardiness (Kobasa) and a greater sense of coherence (Antonovsky) over the
course of the eight-week intervention. These measures indicate a
heightened sense of self and self-in-relationship, and a greater ability
to find coherence and act effectively under high degrees of stress. These
changes enhance the experience of self-efficacy in patients and their view
of the value of engaging in their own on-going health and wellbeing
through meditation, yoga, and above all, the systematic cultivation of
awareness [Kabat-Zinn, Skillings, and Salmon].
A
randomized clinical trial [Kabat-Zinn, Wheeler, et al 1998] showed that
patients with moderate to severe psoriasis undergoing phototherapy or
photochemotherapy, who listened to guided meditation tapes while receiving
the ultraviolet light treatments, healed at approximately four times the
rate of subjects receiving just the light treatments. Since the delivery
of the mind/body element of the intervention was simultaneous and
co-extensive with the conventional UV treatments, it is a classic example
of both integrative and participatory medicine. The observation of an
increased rate of skin clearing among the meditation cohort was seen in
two separate studies. This work suggests that the integration of the
mind/body element into the more conventional medical treatment resulted in
reduced treatment cost (decreased number of treatments to achieve skin
clearing) and in a decreased risk of basal cell carcinoma from the UV
exposure. It also suggests indirectly that the mind can effect a healing
process all the way down to the level of gene expression and control of
the cell replication cycle, which may have implications for carcinogenic
processes. Since the intervention was delivered via an audiotape recording
and in the relative isolation of a light booth, social support variables
in this study were minimized, allowing the researchers to look at
mind/body effects in the absence of this common potential confounder in
group interventions (such as MBSR). For such reasons, this experimental
system provides a fruitful avenue for the further study of mind/body
effects and their psychophysiological pathways and mechanisms.
Another
randomized clinical trial (Davidson et al) took the form of a laboratory
study of MBSR conducted in collaboration with Dr. Richard Davidson of the
Laboratory of Affective Neuroscience at the University of Wisconsin and
the MacArthur Foundation's Mind/Body Network and others. The team looked
at the effects of MBSR training in a workplace setting on brain activity
and on immune response to viral challenge, among other variables.
A
multi-year relationship between the Center For Mindfulness and the team of
Drs. John Teasdale of the Medical Research Council's Cognition and Brain
Sciences Unit, in Cambridge, UK, Mark Williams of the University of Wales,
and Zindel Segal of the University of Toronto and the Clarke Institute of
Psychiatry, has led to the development of a new approach to cognitive
therapy, termed mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, and to major
conceptual advances in the modeling of affective change in depressed
patients [Teasdale, Segal and Williams, 1995; Teasdale, 1999].
The
Center For Mindfulness is also engaged in a number of other research
projects including the introduction of MBSR practices into the Bone Marrow
Transplant Unit, an integrated MBSR/mindful dietary intervention for men
with prostate cancer, and a cost-effectiveness study of MBSR in
conjunction with a large HMO.
Since
1992, in conjunction with two neighborhood health centers, the CFM has
conducted an inner city MBSR program for the multicultural, multi-ethnic
population of Worcester's economically impoverished inner city. This
program is free of charge, with on-site mindful childcare, and free travel
vouchers to minimize common barriers to attendance. Over 2,000 people have
been referred to this program and over 500 have completed it. It is
offered entirely in Spanish as well as in English. The outcomes from this
MBSR clinic are currently being written up for publication. This and the
prison project described below are both examples of integrating mind/body
approaches into settings and institutions within society that might
further individual and community health and well-being and serve as
mitigators to poverty, crime, and violence. At least one other inner city
bi-lingual MBSR clinic has developed based on the UMass model, and has
reported positive results [Roth and Creaser, 1997)].
Between
1992 and 1996, the CFM delivered MBSR programs to over 1,500 inmates and
100 staff (including the Commissioner of Public Safety and several prison
superintendents) of the Massachusetts Department of Corrections, in
collaboration with and under the support of the Massachusetts Committee on
Criminal Justice. Exciting positive outcomes were observed in this
project, and are currently being written up for publication in the
criminal justice literature.
Top
of Page
|
‘Even
in Kyoto –
hearing the cuckoo’s cry –
I long for Kyoto.’
Basho
|
|